1. Grammar TOP
  2. English grammar
  3. B1

Level B1

Relative clauses: whose, where and commas

Say which person, place or thing you mean and add information

In short

With whose, where, who and which, we add a part after a person, place or thing. This part can show which one we mean: the man who called you, the cafe where we met. Or it can add extra information between commas: Tom, who is my neighbour, is a teacher.

Whose means the same as his, her or their: I met a man whose sister lives in Rome. What means "the thing that", with the word order of a positive sentence: I didn't understand what she said. The exercises check each word and explain every answer.

When we use whose, where, who and which

  • where after a place, then a subject and a verb: we met there → the cafe where we met. If a verb comes next, use which or that: a town which has a castle.
  • who without commas: the part shows which person we mean: The man who called you is here.
  • who or which between commas: we add information about a known person or thing: Our car, which is very old, broke down.
  • a preposition at the end: The man I talked to was very nice. It is the same in questions: Who are you talking to?
  • what, and everything that: What he said was true. After everything, all and something, use that or nothing: everything (that) she cooks.

The rule with examples

01whose: belonging to someone

To show which person you mean, say what belongs to them. Put whose and a noun after the person.

Whose means the same as his, her or their here.

That'sthe womanwhose dogbitme

  • I met a man whose sister lives in Rome.
  • I have friends whose parents are doctors.
  • She's a singer whose songs I know.

Don't use who with his or her: not the man who his car was stolen.

02where: places

To show which place you mean, put where after it. Then add a subject and a verb.

We use where instead of there: we met there → the cafe where we met.

If a verb comes next, use which or that, as for things.

Thisisthe cafewhere we met

  • The town where I grew up is small.
  • I know a place where we can park.
  • We live in a town which has a castle.

Say the town where I was born, with no in at the end. Don't say the town which I was born: with which, add in at the end.

03Extra information with commas: who, which

Sometimes we already know the person or thing. Then we add information with who or which between commas.

Use only who or which here: don't use that. And don't leave out who or which.

My sister,who lives in Rome,isa doctor

  • Tom, who is my neighbour, is a teacher.
  • Our car, which is very old, broke down.
  • Anna, who I met in Paris, is coming today.

Without commas, the part with who shows which person you mean.

The manwho called youishere

Don't put commas around every part with who: the man who called you has no commas.

04Preposition at the end: the man I talked to

Some verbs go with a preposition: talk to, look for, wait for. In a part after a noun, the preposition comes after the verb, often at the end.

It is the same as in the question Who are you talking to?

Isthisthe bookyou were looking for

  • The man I talked to was very nice.
  • That's the bus I was waiting for.
  • The music we listened to was great.

Don't add him or it after the preposition: not the man I talked to him.

05what and everything that: the thing that

What means the thing that: what we saw = the thing that we saw. After it, the word order is as in a positive sentence.

After everything, all and something, use that or nothing.

Ididn't understandwhat she said

what: the thing thatthat or nothing: everything that
what he saideverything (that) he said
what I needall (that) I need
what happenedsomething (that) I saw
  • What he said was true.
  • Everything she cooks is great.

Say everything he said, not everything what he said.

Common mistakes

who with his or her. the man whose car was stolen (not: the man who his car was stolen).

which or where with in. the town where I was born or the town which I was born in (not: the town which I was born, the town where I was born in).

Commas around every part. The man who called you is here has no commas (not: The man, who called you, is here).

that after a comma. Tom, who is my neighbour, is a teacher (not: Tom, that is my neighbour, ...).

An extra him or it. the man I talked to (not: the man I talked to him).

what after everything. everything he said (not: everything what he said).

whose in questions and after a person

On the page "Pronouns and possessives", whose starts a question. On this page, whose comes after a person and shows which person we mean.

  • Whose dog is that? We ask about the owner.
  • That's the woman whose dog bit me. Here whose dog = her dog.

Practice

Do the exercises. After each one, you will see an explanation.

  1. 1Choose the right option

    I met a man sister knows you.

    Show answer

    Correct answer: whose

    It is the man's sister, so we use whose. Who's means who is.

  2. 2Fill in the gaps

    The village my grandma lives has a shop sells everything.

    Show answer

    Correct answer: where … which

    The subject my grandma comes after village, so we use where. A verb comes right after shop, so we use which.

  3. 3Complain that your new phone is broken

    Show answer

    Correct answer: My phone, which is new, doesn't work.

    The part which is new only adds information, so we put it between commas. For a thing we use which: who is for people, and we don't use that with commas.

  4. 4Choose the right option

    The woman is my teacher.

    Show answer

    Correct answer: you were talking to

    We say talk to, so to stays at the end. Don't add her: the woman is already there.

  5. 5Fill in the gaps

    I didn't eat he cooked, but everything she cooked was great.

    Show answer

    Correct answer: what … that

    The first part means the thing that he cooked: what. After everything we use that.

  6. 6Fill in the gaps

    Anna is the girl sings in our band. Maria is the girl brother plays the drums.

    Show answer

    Correct answer: who … whose

    A verb comes after the first gap, and Anna is a person. So we use who, not which. Before brother we need whose: her brother.

  7. 7Tell a visitor that you play football in this park

    Show answer

    Correct answer: That's the park where we play football.

    A park is a place, and the subject we comes next. So we use where, not which or what.

  8. 8Choose the right option

    My mother, is a nurse, works at night.

    Show answer

    Correct answer: who

    The part has commas and is about a person, so we use who. We don't use that with commas.

More practice: 17 exercises with answers and a PDF

Frequently asked questions

When do you use whose?

Use whose + noun after a person, instead of his, her or their: I met a man. His sister lives in Rome. → I met a man whose sister lives in Rome.

What is the difference between where and which?

After where, a subject and a verb come next, with no preposition at the end: the town where I was born. With which, the preposition goes at the end: the town which I was born in.

When do you use commas with who and which?

Use commas when we already know the person or thing and only add information: My sister, who lives in Rome, is a doctor. Without commas, the part shows which person or thing we mean: the man who called you.

Can you use that after a comma?

No. Between commas, use only who or which: Our car, which is very old, broke down. And don't leave them out.

Why do we say everything he said, not everything what he said?

What already means "the thing that". After everything, all and something, we use that or nothing: everything he said, everything that he said.

Keep practicing in Grammar TOP

The app has more exercises and review for this topic, to help you remember the rule.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google PlayDownload on the Mac App Store